Logo

"Bad Mother" Ayelet Waldman Says There Is No Work-Life Balance

Maureen Dempsey

Bad MotherAyelet Waldman is a former lawyer, an accomplished fiction writer, and mother to four children. (In fact, she’s even working on a television pilot. Busy woman.) But what you probably know her for is the famous “Modern Love” mayhem of 2005. Waldman explained in the New York Times column how her marriage was solid despite the demands of parenting, work, life. She said she loved her husband more than her children. (Enter mayhem.) The backlash was inextinguishable, but it could have been what set the writer on the path to her latest book, Bad Mother, an examination of the unnecessary judgment we face—and project—everyday as parents. Waldman offers a few of her thoughts on the highs and lows of raising children in the 21st century.

Hybrid Mom: I read an article by a mother who cautioned, “If you and your partner plan to work full-time, don’t have children. Period.” Agree? Disagree?

Ayelet Waldman: I hate to be so adamant about things. Certainly it’s much, much harder if you both work full-time, mostly because of what full-time has come to mean in contemporary American society.

When we were kids, professionals worked until 5 or 5:30. Nowadays, you’re a slacker if you leave the office before 8. I agree it’s not tenable for two parents to work from 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. and expect their children to be happy. Something’s got to give. But the idea of reserving parenthood only for those who have the luxury of a part-time career seems ridiculous to me. I think we need to do a variety of things. 1. Men need to demand more sane hours, because only when men demand them will the workplace change. It’s all well and good for there to be a mommy-track, but until men are rolling down it, it will be second-class. 2. Women need to start their own businesses. A friend of mine was a very successful corporate lawyer, but it became clear that her job was incompatible with the kind of parent she wanted to be. She quit and started her own firm with two other women. She’s got 16 people working for her now, and they are making money hand over fist.

HM: Why do you think there are so few good, career-building part-time work options for parents?

AW: Because there are always people willing to work full-time. My husband and I were recently interviewing agents and I found myself wondering about an incredibly talented pregnant woman, “Will she be quitting soon? Will she be available to him?” I smacked myself across the face (figuratively), but if I’m thinking like this, then everyone is. And it sucks, big time.

HM: Experts, magazines, etc., all offer strategies to achieve “balance.” Do you think that’s possible?

AW: Achieving it? No. Striving for it? Yes.

HM: Do you think it’s more difficult to be a good mother or a good wife?

AW: I think we give ourselves permission to be crappy partners, but we spend far too much time beating ourselves up about being crappy mothers. In my book Bad Mother, I take on this notion of “Bad Mother” and how we keep beating ourselves up about not being good enough, not being there enough. We view our very natural ambivalence as evidence of our failures. I’d love to see all of us just give ourselves and each other a break, allow ambivalence, forgive small failures. Then, there’d be time to do things like take pleasure in our partners. We got married (or civil-unioned!) because we took pleasure in one another’s company. If we forget that, we’re lost.

More from HybridMom.com:

    Pages:
  1. 1
Articles: 

Comments

Love this interview. There is more truth in it than most of us would like to admit. I think we need to continue to examine the world we live in today and the choices we have as parents. I grew up with both parents working full-time... but they were both home by 5:30. There are so many variables today... but the bottom line is, as parents, we're in charge of our relationships with our children... whether we're able to be home with them all day, or not. Quality not quantity is what's important. On the otherhand, I do think there's a judgment towards moms who stay home as well... I hear often that these women have the "luxury" of working part-time or not at all... when in fact, it's simply another choice we can make... and it too, is a choice that comes with sacrifice. We're all in the same boat and the more we learn to respect each other and accept there are no easy answers... perhaps, the less judgmental we will become.

And what if it's NOT a choice? Some of us do not have the luxury of having that choice - we HAVE TO WORK to support the family. My husband has been underemployed and on an unpaid medical leave for a LONG time now so I have been working many long hours a week to try to keep us afloat. I have always supported us because my husband has not been capable of it yet. If I had the choice, and money were not an option, I would have a more part time or self-employed business, letting me spend more time with my child. Instead my husband is at home and does the lion's share of caretaking when she is not in preschool. While this is a wonderful thing and greatly appreciated, the balance issue is completely out of whack for me and I am tired of reading this "choice" issue in every article. Not all women have made the CHOICE to work full time or as hard as they do -- they do it because they have to do it.

I understand where you are coming from. I'm of the mindset that you have to do what's right for you and your family. We start with the cards we are dealt (or the situation we are in) and go from there. We don't walk in each others shoes. None of us want to be made to feel that we are somehow "less" because of the paths we are walking in life.

I feel judged every time I show up at my daughter's pre-school. They always seem surprised to see me. I secretly envy the stay-at-home/part-time worker mom's but I know by working full-time I am providing the best life I can for my daughter.

I am so glad you posted this article! Stigmas are public perceptions of the past, and it takes time and tolerance and forgiveness of ourselves to evolve. I know of parents that are high achievers that kill themselves to do it all. They are the ones that suffer the most. I see moms that are ineffective in parenting and their marriages without any excuses. Of course, when a mom is working two shifts, and the father is consumed with making ends meet, the children do suffer. I think it comes down to choices, we sometimes stay with what is constant rather than happiness. I made a choice and I am happily "unemployed", I own a dance retail store with several employee to free me to be there for my kids after school. I also have a social marketing business that now has over 60 people developing a residual income for their college and to allow us to travel extensively. Passion and balance of family and "work" is the goal.

Ditto "what if it's not a choice"? I get very tired of reading all these articles about women who "made the hard choice not to work full time to be there for their family." There are many women for whom "getting" to make that choice is not an option. How nice and lovely to have a choice whether you work full time or not? Very luxurious if you ask me. Being judged as selfish and a BAD Mom by the community for working full time gets really old. The women I see around my town who "made that tough choice to be there for their kids at home, where they are needed" seem to spend a lot of time during the work week oh... going to pilates, getting pedicures, redecorating their houses, scrapbooking, hanging out at the country club all summer, hitting up TJ Maxx once a week for the best deals , driving Suzy Q to her dance lesson, etc etc. Oh a little bit of volunteering at the school thrown into the mix. Many of these women have cleaning services too! I have been told "oh...you are STILL working huh?" so many times it's just silly. It has been very interesting to see with the economic downturn how many of these women who made the "hard choice" are now scrambling to find some kind, any kind of job to support their families once their husbands were laid off. A little tough since you "retired" at age 32 to "spend time with the kids and now haven't done any type of meaningful networking or real work since. The ones who made the "hard choice" are pretty jealous of me and my fun job now! I'm proud I and my husband together support our family. We both get home at dinnertime and attend all our our kids sports and school activities. We employ a great manny for the few afterschool and life in our house is pretty great. In 10 years the kids are off to college and then what for the stay at home crew? Good luck getting a career back on track after 18 years.

Has anyone considered that it sometimes is NOT a choice to stay at home. When we got married, I was the one to leave my career in scientific research to live in the same State as my husband. He was in school and couldn't transfer. When we had our children, I had to stay at home to support my husband's career. We couldn't afford child care and we do not live near our extended families. It made sense as he had a far greater earning power than I ever could in academic research. When my husband started his own business, I had to abandon all hope of getting back into my original career. I am now working part-time to support our business, using skills that I have taught myself. My three degrees in the sciences are not of much use in accounting. Far from getting my nails painted every week, and coffee mornings, I find myself running from the minute I am awake to 8.00 or 9.00pm. ALL the household, children and running the business responsibilities fall upon my shoulders, because you see, I AM at home after-all. Granted, my husband works hard everyday doing what he loves but he does love his work. I am so tired of the condescending comments like, "you are doing a great job, but don't you miss not working" all too often followed by, "I couldn't do what you do! It would drive me crazy to stay at home." To me this implies, that you must be fine with mind numbing activities. Contrary to the University of Kansas study, my experience has been that more often than not, people consider me as the lazy, underachiever, who has wasted her education and is happy to depend on her husband. My husband says that this is because I myself don't value what I do for our office. But then again, I didn't stay at home by choice! On a final note, after twelve years, I am trying to find a job that will allow me to do my current jobs. Echoing the sentiments of a previous poster "good luck with getting a career back on track...." I am finding that I need to re-invent myself and that even with a PhD, I am simply not having any luck getting any type of career on track.

Thank you for this interview. I have to work. I have given up on expecting work-life balance. Yes, I strive for it, as we all do, but I think there are mere moments when everything feels like it's in place. I used to write "WLB" in my calendar to mean "work-life balance." This might mean lunch, a walk, an errand. (Yes, I schedule personal time.) Now, "WLB" seems more like "work-life blending." I telecommute and sometimes fold laundry during conference calls, or participate in early meetings while I am driving someone to school. This morning, "WLB" meant "work-life battle," as I tried to juggle getting my three sons ready for school and an early meeting.

Balance means you're neglecting someone or something most of the time – your partner, your kids, your parents, your career, your sanity. But the world keeps turning. It's fine to strive for ideals, but that's all they are, and they are inevitably unattainable. Accept your imperfections and allow others theirs. We all have different obligations and address them in our own ways. Of course you should question and evaluate and re-evaluate and learn. The grass is always greener, but it doesn't get that way by itself, and the neighbor's dog will still crap on it. So just be happy.

i love working part-time and being at home with my kids. it's a great balance that works well for my family. every woman should be able to make decisions that work best for her and her family, without judgement!

I agree that we can strive for balance, but will never achieve it. It is a "work in progress" and is over when we are 6 feet under! I have been able to extend my waking hours thanks to 5 cups of coffee a day. It´s not the ideal nor healthiest of decisions, but it could be worse. I figure in order to get through the chaos of work/parenting with five little ones plus a high-maintenance Latin hubby, I gotta abuse something! At least coffee is legal! :)

Some time ago, I did need to buy a good house for my corporation but I didn't have enough cash and could not buy something. Thank goodness my mother suggested to try to get the personal loans at reliable bank. Therefore, I acted so and used to be satisfied with my commercial loan.

Post new comment